As someone who chose to have a cesarean delivery on maternal request, and supports other women who do so, I have always been slightly skeptical of studies that suggest I might have put my children at greater risk for asthma than women who plan vaginal deliveries. This is because most of the studies that suggest an association between cesareans and asthma contain mixed cesarean delivery types (e.g. emergency cesareans and planned cesareans for medical reasons; and the latter often take place prior to the advised 39 weeks EGA for maternal request cesareans).
The study referred to in the Los Angeles Times article below also points to premature birth as a likely risk for asthma, as opposed to the cesarean delivery itself, and adds weight to some of the points I made in my December 2008 blog, "Asthma has NOT been specifically linked with non-medical cesareans".
Article by Thomas H. Maugh II, on February 2, 2010:
An infection of the uterine cavity during pregnancy combined with premature birth doubles the risk that an African American child will develop asthma, researchers have found. The combination also increases risk for some other ethnicities, though less severely.
About 8% of pregnancies are marked by such bacterial infections, called chorioamnionitis, but it is not yet clear what proportion of asthma is induced by them, said the lead author, Dr. Darios Getahun of Kaiser Permanente's Department of Research and Evaluation in Pasadena. Nor is it clear whether the duration of the infection influences the risk and why different ethnicities respond differently, he said.
But blacks have about a 25% higher incidence of asthma and the new findings could account for a significant portion of that increase. Asthma incidence is also higher in American Indian and Alaskan Native populations, but the researchers were not able to examine that association.
About 14% of American children suffer from asthma, an inflammation of the airways that is marked by wheezing, shortness of breath, chest tightening and coughing. About half of such cases are believed to be of genetic origin, but the cause of the rest has been a mystery.
Many studies have looked at the risk of asthma related to caesarean sections, exposure to antibiotics and other factors related to delivery, Getahun said. "We were thinking that it was really exposure [in the uterus] that may predispose children to asthma later in life."
Getahun and his colleagues used the extensive electronic medical records of Kaiser's Southern California Medical Group, studying 397,852 births between 1991 and 2007.
They reported Monday in the journal Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine that chorioamnionitis had no apparent effect on the rate of asthma when the fetuses were carried full term.
But when the mother suffered from the infection and gave birth prematurely, the risk of asthma developing before the age of 8 was 98% higher in black children, 70% higher in Latino children and 66% higher in whites. No increased risk was observed for children of Asian or Pacific Islander descent.
Getahun speculated that the infections -- which can be caused by a broad variety of bacteria -- cause inflammation of the fetal lungs, either injuring the lungs or predisposing them to react more severely to future environmental insults.
Chorioamnionitis is marked by a fever above 100.4 degrees and may also be manifested as increased maternal or fetal heart rate, uterine tenderness, foul-smelling amniotic fluid and increased white blood-cell counts.